Deleted Scenes - Sneering Mechanics

Sneering Mechanics
Movie trailer
Sneering Mechanics_cM
Contributed photo
Location: Calgary, AB, Isaiah Diesel, 2422 9th Ave. SE
GPS:   51d 1m 49s    -114d 0m 30s
Map / Satellite Image: Google Link
Scene Name: Sneering Mechanics
 

Travel Directions:
From the corner of 17th Ave. SE and 9th Ave. SE, proceed SE on 9th Ave. SE approximately 1.4 km. The site is on the north side of 9th Ave SE, opposite Inglewood Wildlands Park.

Remarks:
The Sneering Mechanics scene was placed between Ennis’s meeting with Cassie and Carl in the bus station café and his second post office visit.

153   EXT: GAS STATION: ROAD OUTSIDE CHILDRESS, TEXAS: DAY: 1982:   153

JACK’S truck pulls up to the dirt lot next to the gas station. A MECHANIC, tire jack in hand, fiddling with a car, takes a beer from his BUDDY, who sits on a tire nearby. They both watch as RANDALL gets out of the truck and walks to his own truck parked in the lot, waving back at JACK. The MECHANIC trades knowing glances with his friend.

Their POV:

RANDALL’S truck pulls out of the lot, goes in one direction.

JACK’S pulls out after him, going in the opposite direction.

WIDE:

We hold on JACK’S truck, as it drives off into the distance.

[Script excerpt]

“It was removed to add ambiguity; Lee believes that the harder the audience must work, the better the result,” says a reliable source. There are at least three other excellent arguments for deletion of the Sneering Mechanics scene.

1. It elevates “I wish I knew how to quit you,” and the Dozy Embrace, to their rightful place as Jack’s valediction. Absent the Sneering Mechanics scene, we remember Jack as a man deeply in love, who spent his unhappy life struggling to overcome the consequences of hatred and fear. Could there be a higher honor?

2. It has given rise to literally thousands of hours of vigorous discussion and debate about Jack’s fidelity, and the issue of monogamy in general. Fan websites are awash in lengthy arguments over Jack and his “ranch neighbor friend.” Ennis never knew the truth with certainty, and neither will we.

3. Jack’s fate becomes the film’s much-celebrated mystery. Is Lureen telling the truth? When we witness the murder are we seeing what actually happened or is it Ennis’s imagination at work? Perhaps most intriguing of all, why does it matter to us so?

Pictures of surrounding area:

SneeringMechanics_bS

SneeringMechanics_cS

SneeringMechanics_dS

SneeringMechanics_eS

SneeringMechanics_fS

SneeringMechanics_gS

SneeringMechanics_hS

SneeringMechanics_iS

SneeringMechanics_jS

SneeringMechanics_kS

   

SneeringMechanics_lS

   

***

www.FindingBrokeback.com

  Revised 10 April 2010